(Book Review) Sour Heart by Jenny Zhang

By Katy Goodwin-Bates

Sour Heart gripped me right from the beginning; the collection opens with We Love You Crispina, the story of a young girl and her parents and a series of cramped, unsafe and inhospitable homes in New York. In a move I will go ahead and describe as audacious, Zhang employs just a couple of full stops in the opening few pages, creating a sense of a narrator who simply cannot take a breath, such is her eagerness to share her story. It’s a feeling that carries on throughout Sour Heart, with Zhang’s young protagonists irrepressible in their need to speak.

Back when my parents and I lived in Bushwick in a building sandwiched between a drug house and another drug house, the only difference being that the dealers in the one drug house were also the users and so more unpredictable, and in the other the dealers were never the users and so more shrewd – back in those days, we lived in a one-bedroom apartment so subpar that we woke up with flattened cockroaches in our bedsheets, sometimes three or four stuck on our elbows, and once I found fourteen of them pressed to my calves, and there was no beauty in shaking them off, though we strove for grace, swinging our arms in the air as if we were ballerinas. (We Love You Crispina)

Many of Zhang’s protagonists are children or adolescents, which occasionally lends proceedings an unpleasant degree of self-involvement and a lack of awareness; I was not keen on The Empty the Empty the Empty, in which the child narrator’s voice was possibly the most annoying thing I have ever read. I am confident this was the point, and so Zhang should be commended on the veracity of her writing, but it wasn’t a whole heap of fun to read.

It was the depiction of family relationships in all their inherent complexity which truly sucked me into Sour Heart, most notably in The Evolution of My Brother and Why Were They Throwing Bricks?, both of which convincingly and emotively display the codependency of familial bonds that can sometimes produce the opposite of the intended, happy effect. The former comes from the perspective of one of the collection’s more mature narrators as she describes her evolving relationship with her much younger brother, who worships his sister in his infancy but drifts away as an adolescent. Why Were They Throwing Bricks? is quite heartbreaking in its depiction of a grandmother whose devotion to her grandchildren is suffocating to an almost frightening intensity; it’s a story whose success comes from its ability to create empathy for characters on both sides of the main conflict, as well as conveying a sense of cultural difference and the struggles of those forced to straddle a geographical and cultural divide.

You don’t know how many lonely nights I’ve spent dropping tears for you. It was wrong of me to let you go. Remember how you called for me when you let go of my hand and boarded the airplane with your mother? Remember how you howled that you wanted to take me with you? Four years ago, your father wrote to me, ‘You can’t keep my own wife and child away from me any longer. I’m sending for them immediately.’ I wanted to know if he ever considered maybe you and your mother simply didn’t want to go to America. (Why Were They Throwing Bricks?)

Each story in its own way deals with this sense of separation from one’s culture or origins, with some protagonists rejecting their roots while others return to them only to struggle to fit in and communicate. Even within a community of immigrants, as depicted here, there’s a sense of dislocation, created through the subtle links Zhang draws between the different narratives; for example, in later stories, Crispina of the opening one is mentioned, and it becomes apparent that the different families featured have, at some time, shared a living space. Throughout, there’s a sense of knowing but not really knowing other people, creating isolation and, in some cases, resentment. That said, it’s not a collection that’s particularly bleak, thanks to Zhang’s vibrant, believable writing.

One comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.